Stockchase Opinions

Steve MacMillanCaterpillarCATDON'T BUYJan 03, 2007

Has recently had some issues. Decline in share price is because of slower truck sales as well as rising commodity prices. With manufacturing costs rising, margins will get squeezed. He is generally underweight the whole industrial space in the US.
$61.16

Stock price when the opinion was issued

$904.28

As of Jun 05, 2026. Market Open.

machinery
It's the ideal tool to help you make quicker, more informed decisions for managing and tracking your investments.

You might be interested:

SELL

Yesterday, sold it because CAT moved up a lot in sympathy with United Rentals. They sharp rally changed the risk/reward.

BUY

Will benefit from governemtn infrastructure spending. Likes it.

DON'T BUY

A quality company, but their PE is misleading. Looks cheap, but is highly sensitive to cyclicality. Will buy it one day, not now.

BUY

Just bought it after they delivered a blow-out quarter last time (report next week) with top and bottom line beats. Good dividend growth. He believes in infrastructure long term. Bought this before earnings to start building a position.

BUY ON WEAKNESS

Doesn't see a major recession, and so sees major upside here. They crushed their last quarter. He just bought it on a pullback, will buy again and hold for the long term.

BUY
A big gainer in Q3

They were viewed as a play on China. Given China's collapse, CAT stock should have tanked and shorters piled into this. But the CEO countered that CAT is more levered to data centres, which helped to sway the street. Still trades at 13x PE. Was up 11% in Q3. CAT has more room to run.

BUY

Prefers Caterpillar over John Deere.
Growth in infrastructure spending good for industrial nature of company.
Company subject to broad economic trends.
Good long term investment. 


BUY

Revenue is starting to increase, plus positive momentum.

BUY

He bought it this week. CAT covers industrials from mining to energy and rails.They delivered one of the best quarterly earnings, then broke to new highs. This plays into the rotation theme in which he favours industrials, healthcare and energy in the second half of this year, though not tech.

BUY

Just reported a strong earnings beat and their quarter defied concerns of a global slowdown. Shares rallied to an all-time high. CAT makes machines to non-residential construction, mining, oil/gas and data centre construction--all sectors doing well. Also, Washington is creating tons of jobs in infrastructure. CAT's sell-off was unwarranted in the first place. The CEO is making CAT less cyclical, and he foresaw the weakness in China.

COMMENT

They diversified away from China. CAT will benefit from federal infrastructure spending that will boost their orders. Also, when investors feel that US-China relationships are improving, they buy CAT. He sold some shares today. Has rallied since last May. Is now seeing money from the Infrastructure Bill of late 2021. Trades at 13x PE 2023.

COMMENT

Rallied last Friday. The CEO has diversified the services offered, but shares have slumped. Wall Street views it as an old-fashioned cyclical stock, which is wrong. He expects a lot of orders for infrastructure projects by next year. Shares have bumped because of China's stimulus plans, but China represents only 5% of CAT's business.

WATCH

Great company. Given the debt ceiling talks, CAT can go lower in the next 4-5 days.

HOLD

Core holding. A play on where the next bull market's going to be, and that's going to be cyclicals. Growth rate is fine, as is valuation. He'd go for cheaper names with the same view, think FTT or WJX.

premiumPremium content

🔒 Premium Content Alert – This buzzing stock opinion is accessible only to Stockchase Premium

Discover an exclusive list and analysis of the stocks that are trending on social medias—accessible only to our Premium subscribers. With a keen focus on the stocks that are setting social media ablaze, this weekly feature offers an invaluable lens through which to evaluate market movers. Say goodbye to the endless scroll through social media timelines; we curate the buzz so you can invest your time as wisely as your money. Unlock Premium Now.

TOP PICK

Since 1925, Caterpillar Inc. has been helping our customers build a better world - making sustainable progress possible and driving positive change on every continent. With 2019 sales and revenues of $53.8 billion, Caterpillar is the world's leading manufacturer of construction and mining equipment, diesel and natural gas engines, industrial gas turbines and diesel-electric locomotives. Services offered throughout the product life cycle, cutting-edge technology and decades of product expertise set Caterpillar apart, providing exceptional value to help our customers succeed. The company principally operates through three primary segments - Construction Industries, Resource Industries and Energy & Transportation - and provides financing and related services through its Financial Products segment. Social media mentions are up 1200% in the past 24h.